Bring_me_that_logo

New York Plate - Gary, IN

5808 Melton Rd 2905, Gary, IN 46403
IN > Gary > 46403
Pickup
|
Delivery






Main Menu

Plates

Order New York Plate food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
New York Plate

Gyro & chicken. Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

$20.62
Order The Brooklyn Plate food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
The Brooklyn Plate

Steak & chicken. Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

$22.00
Order The Manhattan Plate food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
The Manhattan Plate

Steak, chicken & gyro. Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

$23.38
Order The New Yorker Nachos Plate food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
The New Yorker Nachos Plate

Lettuce, tomatoes, nacho cheese, hot peppers,sour cream on Doritos.

$17.88
The Bronx Plate

Steak & gyro. Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

$22.00
The Queens Plate

Chicken. Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

$20.62
The Empire Plate

Gyro. Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

$20.62
The Liberty Plate

Steak. Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

$22.00
The Long Island Plate

Fried shrimp. Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

$22.00
The Coney Island Plate

Fried catfish. Onions, green peppers, over rice with pita, salad, New York sauce.

$20.62
Falafel Plate

Lettuce, green pepper, onions, tomato, over rice with pita New York sauce.

$15.12
Gyro Platter

Tomato, lettuce, onions, tzatziki sauce, with fries & 2 pita breads. Add extras for an additional charge.

$20.62
The New Yorker Fries Plate

Lettuce, tomatoes, nacho cheese, hot peppers, New York sauce.

$17.88
Grilled shrimp plate

RICE, GREEN PEEPERS, ONIONS, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, PITA,

$22.00

Sandwiches

Order Gyro Philly Sandwich food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
Gyro Philly Sandwich

Onions, cheese, green peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, tzatziki sauce.

$13.75
Order Gyro Sandwich food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
Gyro Sandwich

Onions, tomatoes, tzatziki sauce. Add feta cheese for an additional charge.

$13.12
Philly Steak Sandwich

Sandiwch with beef steak.

$15.12
Chicken Philly Sandwich

Boneless skinless chicken sandwich.

$15.12
Buffalo Chicken Philly Sandwich

Boneless skinless chicken sandwich.

$15.12
Chicken Teriyaki Philly Sandwich

Sandwich with protein that has been marinated or glazed in a soy based sauce.

$15.12
Brooklyn Philly Sandwich

Steak, chicken.

$16.50
Bronx Sandwich

Steak, gyro.

$16.50
Manhattan Philly Sandwich

Steak, chicken, gyro.

$17.88
Gyro Cheeseburger

Ketchup, mustard, onions, lettuce, tomates, pickles, tzatziki sauce.

$15.12
Double Cheeseburger

Grilled or fried patty with cheese on a bun.

$13.75
Italian Beef Sandwich

Mozzarella cheese, hot peppers.

$15.12
New York Combo Wrap

Gyro, chicken, rice, New York sauce, onions, green peppers, lettuce, tomatoes.

$15.12
Chicken Wrap

Chicken, lettuce, onions, green pepper, tomatoes, New York sauce.

$13.75
Fish Sandwich

Catfish fillet, tarter sauce, lettuce, cheese, tomatoes.

$12.38
Chicken Sandwich

Mayo, lettuce, tomatoes cheese.

$12.38
Chicken on Pita

Mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese.

$15.12

Sandwiches Combo

Philly Steak Sandwich Combo

Sandiwch with beef steak.

$15.88
Chicken Philly Sandwich Combo

Boneless skinless chicken sandwich.

$15.88
Buffalo Chicken Philly Sandwich Combo

Boneless skinless chicken sandwich.

$16.50
Chicken Teriyaki Philly Sandwich Combo

Sandwich with protein that has been marinated or glazed in a soy based sauce.

$16.50
Brooklyn Philly Sandwich Combo

Steak, chicken.

$16.50
Bronx Sandwich Combo

Steak, gyro.

$16.50
Manhattan Philly Sandwich Combo

Steak, chicken, gyro.

$19.25
Gyro Philly Sandwich Combo

Onions, cheese, green peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, tzatziki sauce.

$15.12
Gyro Cheeseburger Combo

Ketchup, mustard, onions, lettuce, tomates, pickles, tzatziki sauce.

$16.50
Double Cheeseburger Combo

Grilled or fried patty with cheese on a bun.

$15.12
Italian Beef Sandwich Combo

Mozzarella cheese, hot peppers.

$16.50
New York Wrap Combo

Gyro, chicken, rice, New York sauce, onions, green peppers, lettuce, tomatoes.

$16.50
Chicken Wrap Combo

Chicken, lettuce, onions, green pepper, tomatoes, New York sauce.

$15.12
Fish Sandwich Combo

Catfish fillet, tarter sauce, lettuce, cheese, tomatoes.

$13.75
Chicken Sandwich Combo

Mayo, lettuce, tomatoes cheese.

$12.38
Gyro Sandwich Combo

Onions, tomatoes, tzatziki sauce. Add feta cheese for an additional charge.

$13.75
Chicken on Pita Combo

Mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese.

$13.75

Salads

Greek Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, feta cheese, pepperoncini pepper, dressing.

$11.00
House Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, green pepper, onions, cucumbers, dressing.

$9.62

Seafood

Order Catfish Fillet food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
Catfish Fillet

$14.50
Ocean Perch

$12.38
Tilapia Fillet

$13.12
Shrimp

$15.88
Jumbo Shrimp

$16.50
Fish & Chips

$15.88
Popcorn Shrimp

$11.00
Clams

$12.38

Chicken & Fish Combo

Chicken & Fish Combo

$15.12

Flaming Hot

Order Flamin hot 6 Cheese Sticks food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
Flamin hot 6 Cheese Sticks

Spicy.

$13.75
Time Square Plate

Spicy.

$22.00
Steak and Gyro Flamin Hot Burrito

Spicy.

$19.25
Hot Cheesburger

Spicy.

$19.25
3 Meat Burrito

Spicy.

$22.00
Chicken Burrito

Spicy.

$19.25
6pc Flamin hot wings

Spicy.

$19.25
flamin hot nacho cheese fries

$13.75

Appetizers

Order Flamin hot Nacho Cheese Fries food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
Flamin hot Nacho Cheese Fries

Fried potatoes topped with cheese.

$12.38
Hummus

Dip made from chickpeas.

$4.12
Hummus with Pita

Dip made from chickpeas.

$5.50
Baba Ghannouj

Dip made from cooked eggplant.

$4.12
Baba Ghannouj with Pita

$5.50
Falafel

Fried ball made from beans.

$6.88
Cheese Sticks

Fried cheese.

$8.25
Okra

$6.88
Mushrooms

$8.25
Fries

Fried potatoes.

$4.62
Tenders

Breaded or battered crispy chicken.

$11.00
Onion Rings

Fried battered onion.

$6.88
Chicken Nuggets

Breaded or battered crispy chicken.

$11.00
Pizza Puff

Fried and stuffed pizza pocket.

$5.50
Pizza Puff with Fries

Fried and stuffed pizza pocket.

$6.88

Chicken Wings

Order 4 Wings food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
4 Wings

Served with fries.

$12.38
Order 5 Wings food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
5 Wings

Served with fries.

$12.38
Order 6 Wings food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
6 Wings

Served with fries.

$13.75
3 Wings

Served with fries.

$11.00
10 Wings

Served with fries.

$23.38
20 Wings

Served with fries.

$41.25
30 Wings

$49.50
40 Wings

$68.75
50 Wings

$90.75

Buffalo Wings

6 Buffalo Wings

$13.75
10 Buffalo Wings

$20.62
12 Buffalo Wings

$23.38
25 Buffalo Wings

$41.25

Desserts

Order Parfait food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
Parfait

$5.50
Order Cheesecake food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
Cheesecake

$5.50
Order Taffy Grapes food online from New York Plate store, Gary on bringmethat.com
Taffy Grapes

$9.62
Cake Squares

$5.50
Butter Cookies

$4.12
Banana Burst

$5.50

Drinks

Snapple

$3.50
Bottle Soda

$2.62
Bottle of Water

$1.38
Can Soda

$1.38

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ Order with AI Reviews