Bring_me_that_logo

Papa bear's bbq (east) - Madison, WI

4527 Cottage Grove Rd, Madison, WI 53716
WI > Madison > 53716
Pickup
|
Delivery






Menu

Breadsticks

9-Pack - Party Size
$10.00
3-Pack Side Sticks
$3.75

Pizza By The Slice

Smokey the Bandit
$5.00
Florentine
$5.00
Mac n' Cheese
$5.00
Traditional Cheese
$3.75
Traditional Pepperoni
$3.75
Cheesy Potato
$5.00
Pepperoni
$3.75
Pepperoni Mushroom
$5.00
Chicken Penne Alfredo
$5.00
Buffalo Chicken and Blue Cheese
$5.00
Chorizo Quesadilla
$5.00
Spicy Chicken Quesadilla
$5.00
Smoked Brisket Tater Tots
$5.00
Ham Penne Alfredo
$5.00
Maui Wowie
$5.00
Chorizo Sweet Potato
$5.00
Spinach, Feta, Pesto
$5.00
Tomato Pesto
$5.00
Mushroom Penne Alfredo
$5.00
Portobello, Pesto, Blue Cheese
$5.00
Chipotle Sweet Potato
$5.00
Shabam
$5.00
Cheese
$3.75
Monthly Special Slice
$5.00
Sausage
$5.00
Sausage Penne Alfredo
$5.00
SHMO
$5.00
Pepperoni Sausage
$5.00

Classic Pizza

Cheese
$11.88
Cheese
$18.44
Cheese
$18.75
Pepperoni
$11.88
Pepperoni
$18.44
Pepperoni
$18.75
Pepperoni Mushroom
$13.12
Pepperoni Mushroom
$20.62
Pepperoni Mushroom
$28.12
Pepperoni Sausage
$13.12
Pepperoni Sausage
$20.62
Pepperoni Sausage
$28.12
Sausage Mushroom
$13.12
Sausage Mushroom
$20.62
Sausage Mushroom
$28.12

Signature Pizza

Buffalo Chicken
$13.12
Buffalo Chicken
$20.62
Buffalo Chicken
$28.12
Florentine
$14.38
Florentine
$22.81
Florentine
$31.25
Mac N' Cheese 12"
$13.12
Maui Wowie
$16.88
Maui Wowie
$27.19
Maui Wowie
$37.50
Spinach Feta Pesto
$13.12
Spinach Feta Pesto
$20.62
Spinach Feta Pesto
$28.12
Tomato Pesto
$13.12
Tomato Pesto
$20.62
Tomato Pesto
$28.12
Chicken Penne Alfredo
$14.38
Chicken Penne Alfredo
$22.81
Chicken Penne Alfredo
$31.25
Ham Penne Alfredo
$16.88
Ham Penne Alfredo
$27.19
Ham Penne Alfredo
$37.50
Portobello Penne Alfredo
$14.38
Portobello Penne Alfredo
$22.81
Portobello Penne Alfredo
$31.25
Macadilla Killa
$15.62
Macadilla Killa
$25.00
Macadilla Killa
$34.38
Portobello Pesto Blues
$14.38
Portobello Pesto Blues
$22.81
Portobello Pesto Blues
$31.25
Spicy Chicken Quesadilla
$15.62
Spicy Chicken Quesadilla
$25.00
Spicy Chicken Quesadilla
$34.38
Smokey the Bandit
$16.88
Smokey the Bandit
$27.19
Smokey the Bandit
$37.50
Chipotle Sweet Potato with Chorizo
$16.88
Chipotle Sweet Potato with Chorizo
$27.19
Chipotle Sweet Potato with Chorizo
$37.50
Chorizo Quesadilla
$15.62
Chorizo Quesadilla
$25.00
Chorizo Quesadilla
$34.38
Cheesy Potato with Ranch
$15.62
Cheesy Potato with Ranch
$25.00
Cheesy Potato with Ranch
$34.38
Chipotle Sweet Potato with Portobello
$16.88
Chipotle Sweet Potato with Portobello
$27.19
Chipotle Sweet Potato with Portobello
$37.50
BBQ Brisket and Tots
$16.88
BBQ Brisket and Tots
$27.19
BBQ Brisket and Tots
$37.50
SH-BAM
$16.88
SH-BAM
$27.19
SH-BAM
$37.50
Mac N' Cheese 16"
$20.62
Mac N' Cheese 20"
$28.12
Sausage Penne Alfredo
$14.38
Sausage Penne Alfredo
$22.81
Sausage Penne Alfredo
$31.25
SHMO
$14.38
SHMO
$22.81
SHMO
$31.25

Build Your Own Pizza

Build Your Own 12" Pizza
$9.38
Build Your Own 16" Pizza
$14.06
Build Your Own 20" Pizza
$18.75
[VEGAN] Build Your Own 12" Pizza
$9.38
[VEGAN] Build Your Own 16" Pizza
$14.06
[VEGAN] Build Your Own 20" Pizza
$18.75

Signature Salads

Caesar Salad
$8.75
Greek Salad
$10.00
Southwest Salad
$8.12
Wisco Salad
$11.25
Side Caesar
$4.38
Ian's House Side Salad
$4.38
Party Size Southwest Salad
$25.00
Party Size Greek Salad
$30.00
Party Size Wisco Salad
$37.50
Party Size Caesar Salad
$27.50
Potato Salad
$10.00

From The Greens Up

Build Your Own Salad
$4.38

Beverages

San Pelligrino Sparkling Water
$2.50
Izzes
$2.50
Horizon Organic Milk
$2.50
Soda - 2 Liter
$3.12
Soda - Can
$1.25
Xing Teas
$2.50
Purity Organic Drink - Kale
$5.00
Purity Organic Drink - Orange
$5.00
Purity Organic Drink - Beet
$5.00
Boxed Water
$2.50
Cadence Cold Brew
$3.75

Extras

Puppy Chow
$2.50
Sides
$1.25
Uncooked Dough
$3.75
Uncooked Dough
$6.25

Calliope Ice Cream

Brandy Old Fashioned Ice Cream
$7.50
Graham Cracker Ice Cream
$7.50
Mexican Hot Chocolate Ice Cream
$7.50
Spicy Peanut Butter Ice Cream
$7.50
Hearty Breakfast Ice Cream
$7.50
Lemon Lavendar Ice Cream
$7.50
Chocolate Crispy Rice Treat
$7.50

Seasonal Signature Salads

Strawberry Ginger Salad
$10.00
Beet Salad
$10.00

Monthly Featured Pizzas

Crab Rangoon
$16.88
Crab Rangoon
$27.19
Crab Rangoon
$37.50
Bacon Cheeseburger
$16.88
Bacon Cheeseburger
$27.19
Bacon Cheeseburger
$37.50
Eggplant Parmesan & Pesto (V)
$16.88
Eggplant Parmesan & Pesto (V)
$27.19
Eggplant Parmesan & Pesto (V)
$37.50
Italian Meat Sandwich - Staff Favorite!!
$16.88
Italian Meat Sandwich - Staff Favorite!!
$27.19
Italian Meat Sandwich - Staff Favorite!!
$37.50
Philly Cheesesteak
$16.88
Philly Cheesesteak
$26.88
Philly Cheesesteak
$37.50

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ Order with AI Reviews